What to Expect When Beginning a Litigation Case: A Practical Guide for Plaintiffs and Defendants
Attorney Brenton Begley
Litigation can be an intimidating process, whether you’re initiating a lawsuit or responding to one. This guide walks through what to expect from start to finish, providing practical insights for both plaintiffs and defendants. We’ll cover not only legal strategy but also key considerations like budgeting, discovery, and the role of settlement.
Plaintiff's Litigation Case Flow
Initial Case Evaluation
When you begin the litigation process, your attorney will first focus on identifying your goal. Are you seeking financial compensation, a court order, or some other form of relief? Your legal team will assess whether that goal is realistic—both from a legal and practical standpoint.
Next, your attorney will evaluate all potential legal claims (called “causes of action”) under both state and federal law. Each claim has specific deadlines, called statutes of limitations, that determine whether a case can be filed in time.
To organize your case effectively, your attorney will develop a litigation chart. This chart breaks each potential claim into its required legal components and matches those elements with available evidence. This includes both informal evidence—like your own recollections, texts, or photos—and formal evidence that will be gathered later during the discovery phase. Your attorney will also identify any gaps and determine how to address them.
Your legal team will also begin gathering facts informally. This can involve interviewing you and other witnesses, collecting key documents, and searching public records. This early work lays the foundation for a strong case.
Estimated Timeline:
- Common Case: 1–3 weeks
- Complex Case: 1–2 months
Pre-Filing Strategy
Before filing a lawsuit, your attorney will draft a litigation timeline that outlines major steps and deadlines. They’ll also provide a budget estimate, which you’ll review and approve so expectations are clear from the start.
Your lawyer will also assess risks in the case. This includes anticipating how the other side may defend themselves—such as blaming you, denying responsibility, or claiming you didn’t mitigate damages. Evaluating these risks early helps shape a smarter strategy.
Settlement will be discussed from the outset. Your attorney may recommend sending a demand letter or attempting early negotiations, depending on the situation. Even if the case proceeds to court, staying open to settlement can help avoid the time, cost, and uncertainty of trial.
Estimated Timeline:
- Common Case: 2–4 weeks
- Complex Case: 1–3 months
Filing and Litigation Management
Once the groundwork is laid, your attorney will prepare and file the official complaint. They will ensure the case is filed in the right court and that the other party is properly served with legal papers.
Litigation is deadline-driven. Your legal team will maintain a calendar tracking every critical date—from early conferences and discovery deadlines to the final trial date.
Discovery is the formal evidence-gathering phase. Your attorney will send requests for documents, ask written questions, and take depositions. They may also involve expert witnesses if specialized knowledge is needed.
Throughout the process, your attorney will maintain regular communication. You’ll likely have scheduled updates—monthly or around major events—and your legal team will keep records of all advice given and decisions made.
You may encounter legal motions, such as requests to dismiss the case or seek summary judgment. Your attorney will respond to these and may file their own motions to narrow the issues or win the case outright.
If the case proceeds to trial, your attorney will prepare thoroughly—organizing exhibits, prepping witnesses, and developing a compelling theme. They’ll also help you understand what to expect in court.
After trial, your legal team will advise on next steps, whether that means enforcing a favorable judgment or pursuing an appeal if the outcome isn’t what you hoped.
Estimated Timeline:
- Complaint Filing: 1–2 weeks
- Discovery Phase: 3–6 months (common), 6–18 months (complex)
- Trial Preparation: Begins 1–3 months before trial
- Trial Duration: 1–5 days (common), several weeks (complex)
- Post-Trial Issues: 1–2 months, with appeals potentially taking 6–12 months or more
Defendant's Litigation Case Flow
Intake and Early Analysis
If you’ve been sued, your attorney’s first job is to assess the risk. Are you facing financial loss, reputational harm, or a court order? Understanding these stakes helps determine whether to settle early or aggressively defend the case.
Your attorney will analyze the complaint thoroughly, breaking down each claim to see what the plaintiff must prove. They’ll look for any weaknesses, legal defenses, or opportunities to dismiss the case at an early stage.
If appropriate, they may file a motion to dismiss, especially if the lawsuit was filed in the wrong court or lacks legal merit.
Investigation and Case Mapping
Your legal team will build a defense strategy by mapping out how to challenge each part of the plaintiff’s claims. This includes collecting your records and preparing for formal discovery.
A document preservation notice may be issued to make sure no important evidence is lost. Your attorney will also guide you in gathering relevant emails, texts, and documents.
You’ll be educated on the process, including expected timelines, costs, and possible outcomes. Transparency at this stage helps avoid surprises down the line.
Litigation Management
You’ll either file a legal response (called an answer) or a motion to dismiss the case. Your attorney will also assert any counterclaims you may have.
Discovery goes both ways. Your attorney will request evidence from the plaintiff and challenge their claims using your documents, expert opinions, and witness testimony.
Your legal team may also file motions during this time—such as to compel responses or to protect against overly broad requests. If the facts support it, they may move for summary judgment to try and win the case without a trial.
Settlement discussions may take place at various stages. If insurance is involved, your attorney will coordinate with the insurer as needed.
Trial preparation includes crafting your defense narrative, cross-examining the plaintiff’s witnesses, and preparing you for testimony. If the outcome is unfavorable, your attorney will evaluate options for appeal.
Trial vs. Settlement: Managing Uncertainty
While trials can offer closure, they’re also unpredictable. Judges and juries can interpret evidence differently than expected. For this reason, your attorney will likely advise you to consider settlement at multiple stages of the case.
Take Action: Secure Your Future Today
Litigation should always be guided by the question: what outcome best serves your goal—and how can your attorney help you achieve it with the least risk and most control?
Whether you’re pursuing justice or defending your rights, a clear legal roadmap is your best ally.
📍 Offices in Shelby, Charlotte, and Hendersonville
📞 Call us at 1-888-999-6600
🌍 Visit our website: www.mcelderlaw.com
Don’t wait until it’s too late—take control of your future today!
Attorney Brenton Begley
Chief Legal Officer, Attorney
McIntyre Elder Law
Shelby, NC
